Tuesday, May 6, 2014

Thursday May 8th Summit II Agenda

More than one service provider has recently inquired about not only Connect America Phase II funding, but also other funding sources and New Market Tax Credits and such.  Yes, I've been following New Market Tax Credits since 1999, when I went to Hazard, Kentucky to see former President Clinton's speech, as he was launching the New Markets Tax Credit initiative.  I had heard when his visit was announced, that no acting American President had visited Appalachia since before I was born, when former President Lyndon B. Johnson launched the War on Poverty (50 years ago).  Anyway, it's short notice for posting an Agenda - but if a small group is able to arrive in Duffield on Thursday morning, I think that, once again, participants will find the Summit to be interesting and helpful.  Here's the agenda:

Connect America Summit II

AGENDA
  
Thursday, May 8, 2014 – Pioneer Center in Duffield, Virginia

10:00AM – 10:20AM   Introduction and Overview – Connect America Summits

Upcoming Rural Broadband Deployment Funding Opportunities:

10:20AM – 10:35AM  New FCC Connect America – 2014 Rural Broadband Experiments

10:35AM – 10:50AM  Annual USDA RUS broadband deployment programs, 2014 definitions

10:50AM - 11:05AM  New USDA RUS 2014 Farm Bill - Rural Gigabit Network Pilot Projects

11:05AM – 11:10AM  New Appalachian Regional Commission 2014 distressed counties

Access to Capital and Credit in Appalachia and the Digital state of Cumberland:

11:10AM – 11:25AM  CDFI Fund - Bank Enterprise Awards grants deadline June 2, 2014

11:25AM – 11:40AM  CDFI Fund - New Markets Tax Credit (from 1999 in Hazard KY to 2014)

Rural Broadband Deployment Dialogue:

11:40AM – 11:50AM  Rural Broadband Experiments – The national dialogue happening now!

11:50AM – NOON  Plans for Connect America Summit III – Thursday, June 12, 2014 from 10am – noon at the Pioneer Center in Duffield, Virginia  

Registration fee is $89 per person.  Registration is required.  To register, email joan@appalachianresources.com or call (276) 445-4600.  The Pioneer Center is located at 225 Boone Trail Road in Duffield, Virginia.  


March 2014 FCC workshop commentary

I only recently started paying attention, because when "Connect America" was first launched, there were no competitive grants.  Now there's "Connect America Phase II" kicking in, and it's offering competitive grants. I may have never tuned in to what was happening, if not for The Daily Yonder... which is exactly why they exist, to get the word out regarding rural issues.  Well, they explain it better at their website.

Years ago, I signed up for The Weekly Yonder emails, which guide me to The Daily Yonder articles.   It's a wonderful, free service and a great website.  So it's March 19th and I'm opening The Weekly Yonder email.  I see this article by Jonathan Chambers at the FCC posted.  I'm reading the article and realize that the FCC is promoting a workshop, and the workshop is about to begin.  Here's a copy of my facebook posts that day:

"LOVE my rural Fiber-to-the-Home. The Daily Yonder's email this morning revealed to me that the FCC is having a workshop today in D.C. about Rural Broadband... making me think "daggone, I'd like to be in that room today" and sure enough, a few more clicks, and VIOLA! I'm IN the room, got into the room before they even started their presentations -- thanks to their live stream!! Enjoying watching this already! I remember the days when you had to actually GO to D.C. to be in the room during a workshop. LOVE THIS!!"

"It's a GREAT workshop! Here's a funny phrase: "We are rural. We are connected. We are an anomaly." They are showcasing a success model of "broadband applications" in rural SD school district where EVERY student has an ipad AND 24/7 broadband access. The English teacher's explanation of how she gets to use the Internet for their "textbook" was an excellent presentation, except this could create some concerns, in my opinion, "I am accessible to students 24/7."

Here's another cool quote, "The Internet allows free-lance consultants to remain in rural areas." She's a librarian in Maine.

Somebody's stock value just went up... as a presenter just pumped a particular company's equipment which just "recently, finally, reached FCC certification..." what a hoot! And they want to install it at every library... probably wants the FCC to require and finance it too.... lol. pardon my sarcasm. gotta luv America!

WAY cool - folks watching online ARE sending in questions via email, and the moderators are compiling the similar questions coming in online and providing responses to them. We've got two-way communications running! woohooo! you go FCC! question # 1: affordability

Yes, getting broadband into remote rural areas can be expensive. I recently compiled that stats. My firm has written 9 successful federal rural broadband deployment grants for 3 clients in two states, totaling $7,049,477 in grant awards over an 8-year period (2005 - 2012). I got slammed in The Washington Post for the 2005 grant having the audacity to get a $506,048 grant to serve a community with a population of 714. (That'd be $708 "per person.") The 2012 grant for $1,059,704 was to get to a community with a population of 15. (That'd be $70,646 "per person.") And then we ran out of eligible communities?! Although none of these numbers reflect how many homes got hooked up along the way to the remote community.... How do I put that into a "marketing" sentence? "Need a federal rural broadband deployment grant? Our extensive experience with federal broadband grants has enabled our firm to increase the grant award from $708 per person to $70,646 per person." ring! ring! I hear The Washington Post reporter calling me again! lol. and to think that I complain about penny stock scams. lol. then again, I recently figured out that the penny stock scammers are running in not only the alternative energy sector, but also the telecommunications sector as well. oh well!  http://www.washingtonpost.com/.../04/22/AR2009042203637.html

Asheville NC is in the room in DC. Shenandoah Valley Virginia is in the room in DC. The Shenandoah Valley Virginia feller is talking about "cows, chickens and trees" while describing his service area.

wish there was a facebook group running for all the workshop participants today. lol

woohoo! lunch break. reconvene at 1:30PM.

GREAT presentation from the lady in California regarding USA broadband maps which are used to determine "unserved" and "underserved" areas -- as she showed that our national maps show "advertised" areas served -- which are very different than "actual" areas served! woohooo! kudos to the California lady, Catherine Sandoval.

and here's a story about an investigative journalist in West Virginia who became a broadband grant scambuster! http://www.dslreports.com/.../Dysfunctional-West-Virginia...

One of the participants asked, "How much money it going to be made available and what can you use it for?" Answer: "Nothing has been decided." Meanwhile, the FCC just got over 1000 responses during a public comment period -- and they do seem to be gearing up for spending a bunch of money on USA rural broadband deployment again... they're just trying to figure out how best to use the money??

Of course there's lots of talk about bandwidth and speed. One thing that EVERYONE in the room agrees on: fiber-to-the-home is the ULTIMATE connection. They call it "future-proof." My Internet connection is "future-proof" ! woohoo!

Connect America Summit I Summary

First, to re-cap, here was our agenda for last month's Connect America Summit:

Connect America Summit
April 10, 2014 – Pioneer Center in Duffield VA
AGENDA
 10:00AM – 10:20AM   Introduction and Overview – Connect America Phase II
 10:20AM – 11:20AM  Three Case Studies – Connect America Phase II
 Case Study # 1 - “digital state of Cumberland” – 9 counties in 3 states (Lee, Scott, and Wise Counties in Virginia; Claiborne, Hancock and Hawkins Counties in Tennessee; Bell, Harlan and Letcher Counties in Kentucky)
Case Study # 2 – Cumberland Plateau Planning District – 4 counties in 1 state (Russell, Tazewell, Dickenson and Buchanan in Virginia)
Case Study # 3 – Madison County, North Carolina
11:20AM – 11:40AM  Brief overview of FCC information, FCC maps, Census maps, and other websites offering more information about Connect America Phase II
11:40AM – 11:50AM  Rural broadband experiments – The national dialogue happening now!
11:50AM – NOON  Plans for Connect America Summit II – Thursday, May 8, 2014 10am – noon at the Pioneer Center in Duffield

Five people representing 3 broadband Internet service providers participated in the Summit on April 10, 2014.  Together, they provide 3 types of services (FTTH, HFC and wireless) and serve portions of 3 states (Virginia, Kentucky, and Tennessee).  I didn't ask anyone to complete a "customer satisfaction survey" or "presenter evaluation form" after the workshop, but based on the comments and on-going dialogue after the Summit, the participants expressed that the Summit information and group discussion were interesting and helpful.

Some of the information provided in the handouts is copied below:

Connect America Phase II
Where do I find information?
Go to http://www.fcc.gov/encyclopedia/connecting-america  for an overview and related links about Connect America.
Go to http://www.fcc.gov/encyclopedia/rural-broadband-experiments for more information about competitive funding available through Connect America Phase 2.
Where is the list of Connect America Phase 2 “eligible census tracts” http://transition.fcc.gov/bureaus/wcb/ExperimentEligibleLocationsPN020514.csv
Where is the replay video for the March 19th workshop? http://www.fcc.gov/events/rural-broadband-workshop
Where do I find maps showing census tracts?  Go to www.census.gov.  Click on “geography.”  Click on “maps and data.”  Click on “reference maps.”  Click on “census reference maps.”  Click on “census tract maps – 2010.”  Select state.  Select county.  Click on the pdf file.

CASE STUDY # 1 –
Examples of Expressions of Interest filed pertaining to this geographic area

Commonwealth of Kentucky, Frankfort KY
Network will cover over 3,100 fiber miles (Middle Mile and targeted Community Anchor Institutions).  “As part of this build out, extra capacity will be included that will be leased to other service providers, enabling improved service to these underserved areas.” All of Kentucky’s 120 counties.  One-time funding $126 million and $38 million over a ten-year period. Total $164,000,000.

Center on Rural Development, Somerset KY
Focus on fiberoptic middle mile infrastructure and anchor institutions across southern and eastern KY, nearly 40 counties (including Bell, Harlan and Letcher).  Seeks to identify new opportunities for competitive commercial providers.
$57 million construction (one-time capital infrastructure investment)
$1.5 million per year for two years (maintenance and operational costs)
Total $60 million estimate

TV Service, Inc. (TVS Cable), Hindman KY
Letcher County census tract 9506, includes Hallie and Roxana ($139,693 annual support)
“TVS Cable provides access to high-speed broadband, voice and video, to residents and businesses in Knott, Letcher, Perry, Floyd and Leslie Counties.  TVS Cable passes approximately 20,000 premises in these counties with a 60% take rate.”
Planning to offer FTTH.  Proposed premises passed: 2,500.  Estimate 60% take rate to serve 1,500 customers.  Total construction costs estimate $8,440,000.  Estimated annual CAF $136,693.

Harlan Community Television, Harlan KY
Currently serves 7 of Harlan County’s 11 census tracts, approximately 2,100 Internet customers.  Proposes to provide faster speeds at the same price for customers.  One-time investment of $200,000 for equipment and assistance with monthly recurring charge for bandwidth.

CASE STUDY # 2 -
Examples of Expressions of Interest filed pertaining to this geographic area

BVU OptiNet/CPC Company, Bristol VA
Partnership with CPC Company (formed by Cumberland Plateau Planning District Commission)
Eight counties, includes Russell, Tazewell (except 1 eligible census tract), Buchanan (except 1 eligible census tract) and Dickenson.  FTTP for on-route locations (within ½ mile of the Middle Mile backbone) and wireless for off-route locations.  Total projected last mile connections (including both wireline and wireless): 5,554.  Funding request $37,743,109.

Scott County Telephone Cooperative/Virginia Coalfield Coalition, Gate City VA
Seven Virginia counties (Lee, Scott, Wise, Russell, Tazewell, Buchanan, Dickenson) and Harlan County, KY.  Hybrid of FTTP and fixed wireless.  Estimated cost for 8-county region $60,000,000.

WVVA.net Inc./Tazewell County and Town of Tazewell
Hybrid network of Fiber and Fixed wireless for all eligible Tazewell County census tracts.
Estimated cost to be determined after engineering.